WATCHLIST · OCTOBER 21, 2026 · 4 min read
September 2026 Rankings Watchlist: Moved Without a Punch Thrown
Ryan Garcia won in 4:25 and rose. Hamzah Sheeraz gave up a belt and didn't fall. José Valenzuela dropped five places idle. Five rankings that don't add up.
By Carrington Dennis
The fighters in this piece

Only one September result moved the rankings: Ryan Garcia's two-round stoppage of Conor Benn, which every board absorbed within days. The other four names here moved without a punch being thrown, or stayed put when the evidence said they shouldn't. One vacated a world title, one dropped five places without fighting, and two are rated on fights that are either a year and a half old or about to be rematched. On two of those four, the call in question is ours, and we say so.
Ryan Garcia — the one result the boards got right
Ryan Garcia (26-2) made the first defence of his WBC welterweight title on September 12 at T-Mobile Arena. He dropped Conor Benn (25-2) with a right hand in the second round and the referee stopped it at 1:25 of that round, 4:25 of fighting in total. ESPN's next divisional update put him second at 147, and so did The Ring. TBRB moved him to third.
That is the system working: a clear result, reflected inside a week. The only remaining split is TBRB keeping Teófimo López (23-2) a place above him, on the strength of López's August 22 majority decision over Rolando Romero (17-3), scored 114-114, 115-113 and 116-112. We moved Garcia to second on our welterweight board and López to third. A stoppage inside two rounds tells you more than a majority decision with one card scored even.
Hamzah Sheeraz — a vacated belt the top of the list hasn't noticed
Hamzah Sheeraz (24-0-1) gave up the WBO super middleweight title on September 18. Queensberry had won the purse bid for his mandatory defence against Janibek Alimkhanuly (17-0), and Sheeraz vacated within days. He had won the belt in May and defended it once, the July majority decision over Simon Zachenhuber we covered in the July–August watchlist.
ESPN's divisional page, updated again on October 16, still rates him second in the world at 168 and still labels him WBO champion. TBRB rates him eighth and The Ring ninth. In August we called him "priced twice." The price has now split further apart, because one of the two things propping up ESPN's number no longer exists. We dropped him from fourth on our super middleweight board on the same evidence: one belt, now gone, and no win over anyone in our top five. Léster Martínez (21-0-1) moved up to fourth and Jaime Munguía (46-2), who holds the WBA title, came in at fifth.
José Valenzuela — five places lost without a fight
José Valenzuela (16-3) last fought on June 28. He avenged his 2022 loss to Edwin De Los Santos (17-3) with a right hook at 2:05 of the second round in Las Vegas. On September 15 ESPN moved him from its lightweight top five to tenth, and he hadn't fought since that knockout. Its October 16 update dropped him out of the top ten altogether. TBRB still has him fourth, and The Ring ninth.
He was fifth on our lightweight board into October, and on our own consensus rule he no longer qualified: Sam Noakes (19-1) is fifth on both ESPN and The Ring once Shakur Stevenson (25-0), who holds his title at 140, is set aside. Noakes also has the fresher win, a unanimous decision over Denys Berinchyk on August 29 (100-90, 99-91, 98-92), and his only loss is to Abdullah Mason (21-0), who is third on our board.
We held the change until Floyd Schofield and Lucas Bahdi had fought for the vacant WBA title, so we would only have to make the call once. Schofield (20-0) won it on a unanimous decision in Chicago on October 10. Two days later we moved Noakes in at fifth and took Valenzuela off. Schofield, now third on The Ring's list and fifth on TBRB's, isn't on ours.
Marilyn Badillo Amaya — rated on a loss a year and a half old
Marilyn Badillo Amaya (19-1-1) is still ESPN's second-best women's flyweight in its October 14 update. Her last fight was on April 19, 2025, in Oceanside, California, against Gabriela Fundora (18-0). It ended in the seventh round, when she took a knee and didn't want to continue. She hasn't fought since, and ESPN lists her next fight as TBA. TBRB doesn't have her in its top five.
We launched our women's rankings on September 18 and put her fourth on the flyweight board. The field below Fundora is thin, and she was unbeaten in 20 fights before that loss. But a number held up by a fight a year and a half old, and that fight a loss, is the same thing we criticise the other boards for. If she hasn't fought by the end of the year, the slot goes to someone who has.
Fabio Wardley — top five everywhere except here
Fabio Wardley (20-1-1) is fourth at heavyweight on ESPN and on TBRB, and The Ring's fifth contender. He isn't on our heavyweight board, which ends at Filip Hrgović (21-1). The reason is his last fight. He put Daniel Dubois (23-3) down in the first round and again in the third at Co-op Live on May 9, then lost his WBO title on an 11th-round stoppage, his right eye badly swollen.
On résumé alone, a strong case says he belongs above Hrgović. We are holding him out until his rematch with Dubois at the O2, set for October 17, because that fight decides the question in the ring. A win would put him straight into our top five. A second loss would leave the other boards explaining why a fighter beaten twice by the WBO champion is still rated fourth.
Where each case lands: Garcia's rise held up on every board, and Sheeraz is overrated by exactly one of them, for a belt he no longer holds. The other three are about inactivity and what a list does with it. ESPN punished Valenzuela for it, while ESPN and our own board both forgave it in Badillo's case. We kept Wardley out on a loss the other three boards have already moved past.
Schofield–Bahdi on October 10 settled the lightweight question, and we acted on it. Dubois–Wardley 2 at the O2 settles the heavyweight one. Badillo's only gets settled if she fights.