Have Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan ever fought each other?

Yes. Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan met once on October 23, 1908, and Jimmy Reagan won by PTS.

Who has the better record, Menney or Reagan?

Eddie Menney is 0-3-1 across the 5 bouts Kill The Body has tracked and Jimmy Reagan is 25-33-15. Jimmy Reagan has the higher win percentage. Records shown as tracked have not yet been independently verified as complete career totals.

Do Menney and Reagan have any common opponents?

Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan share 3 common opponents: Monte Attell, Jimmy Walsh and Willie Ritchie. Eddie Menney fared better against 2 of them.

How much fight data does Kill The Body have on Menney and Reagan?

This comparison is drawn from 5 bouts tracked for Eddie Menney and 73 bouts tracked for Jimmy Reagan. Method and activity splits reflect those bouts only.

Eddie Menney vs Jimmy Reagan — Records, Stats & Common Opponents

Eddie Menney

🇺🇸UNITED STATES

Jimmy Reagan

Eddie Menney (0-3-1 across 5 tracked bouts) and Jimmy Reagan (25-33-15) are compared on record, finishing method, activity, and common opponents on Kill The Body. The two have met once. They share 3 common opponents.

Menney

Tracked record

0–3–1

counted from 5 bouts Kill The Body has ingested

Reagan

Wins

Losses

Draws73 tracked bouts

Heads up: at least one of these records is a tracked record — the wins and losses Kill The Body has ingested so far, not an independently verified career total. Treat the comparison as a read on the bouts we hold, not a settled ledger.

Head to Head

Reagan leads 1–0

Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan have met 1 time; Reagan leads 1–0.
Met	1908Oct 23	Series
Eddie MenneyFighter A	LLost	0–1W–L
Jimmy ReaganFighter B	WWon	1–0W–L
Result	PTSReagan vs Menney	1Meeting

Reagan vs Menney · Oct 23, 1908

The Numbers

Menney 1 · Reagan 3 of 4 measurable rows

MenneyEdge = longer wingReagan

Record^†: 0-3-125-33-15 (edge)
Win %0–100%: 12.5%
44.5% (edge)
Wins by knockoutlevelmax 0: 0
0
KO ratenot comparable: —0%
Stoppage rate (tracked wins)^‡not comparable: —20%
Times stopped^‡max 5: 0 (edge)
5
Title reignslevelmax 0: 0
0
Bouts per year^§max 6.1: 2.8
6.1 (edge)
Bouts trackedcoveragemax 73: 5
73

† One or both records are tracked, not career-verified. · ‡ Counted from bouts Kill The Body has ingested, not a career total. · § Across each fighter's tracked career span. · Bars are scaled per row — percentages on 0–100, counts against the larger of the two. Every figure is also printed as text.

Tale of the Tape

Heightnot held: Eddie Menney: No height on file; Jimmy Reagan: 5′3″
Agenot held: Eddie Menney: No date of birth; Jimmy Reagan: Died aged 84
Stance: Eddie Menney: Not recorded; Jimmy Reagan: Orthodox

Eddie Menney left, Jimmy Reagan right, as everywhere on this page. Age is stated, not scored — neither age nor stance carries an edge.

How They Win

Tracked bouts only

Eddie Menney0 wins · from 5 tracked bouts

No tracked wins for Menney yet.

Jimmy Reagan25 wins · from 73 tracked bouts

5 by KO/TKO 20%17 on the cards 68%3 by another method or unrecorded 12%

One square per tracked win. Counted from the bouts Kill The Body has ingested for each fighter — Eddie Menney 5, Jimmy Reagan 73 — not from a career-complete method table.

Common Opponents

3 shared

3 shared · Menney better on 2 · Reagan better on 13 shared · Eddie Menney better on 2 · Jimmy Reagan better on 1

MenneyEddie Menney

Opponent

ReaganJimmy Reagan

Eddie Menney
Draw, PTS
1907May 1907
AttellMonte AttellUnited States 66–41–28Menney betterEddie Menney better — 0–0–1 to 0–2–2
Jimmy Reagan
0–2–2 against
Draw, PTS
1911Jul 1911
Loss, KO 4
1909Aug 1909
Loss, PTS
1909Feb 1909
Draw, PTS
1908Nov 1908
Eddie Menney
0–2 against
Loss, NWS
1908May 1908
Loss, PTS
1907Mar 1907
WalshJimmy WalshUnited States 57–19–27 · BantamweightReagan betterJimmy Reagan better — 1–0 to 0–2
Jimmy Reagan
Win, PTS
1909Jan 1909
Eddie Menney
No contest, NC
1908Dec 1908
RitchieWillie RitchieUnited States 45–14–17Menney betterEddie Menney better — 0–0 to 0–1
Jimmy Reagan
Loss, PTS
1908Jul 1908

Both sides are set at the same size on purpose. Kill The Body does not score a second-round knockout above a split decision — the edge counts losses first and wins as the tiebreak, and the rest is yours to argue. Shared opponents are matched on fighter identity, not on name, so two different fighters with the same name never merge into one row.

Current Form

Oldest left · newest right

Eddie Menney last boxed on Dec 29, 1908 — 43,032 days ago. Menney had a no contest in the most recent tracked bout with Willie Ritchie.LDLLNC

Walsh Mar 1907Attell May 1907Walsh May 1908Reagan Oct 1908Ritchie Dec 19082.8 tracked bouts per year

Jimmy Reagan has won once since four straight losses. Reagan last boxed on Nov 26, 1919.LLLLW

Read Apr 1918Hanlon Feb 1919Matthews May 1919Adair May 1919Fanning Nov 19196.1 tracked bouts per year

Common Questions

With the rows behind them

Have Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan ever fought each other?: Yes. Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan met once on October 23, 1908, and Jimmy Reagan won by PTS.
Who has the better record, Menney or Reagan?: Eddie Menney is 0-3-1 across the 5 bouts Kill The Body has tracked and Jimmy Reagan is 25-33-15. Jimmy Reagan has the higher win percentage. Records shown as tracked have not yet been independently verified as complete career totals.
Do Menney and Reagan have any common opponents?: Eddie Menney and Jimmy Reagan share 3 common opponents: Monte Attell, Jimmy Walsh and Willie Ritchie. Eddie Menney fared better against 2 of them.
How much fight data does Kill The Body have on Menney and Reagan?: This comparison is drawn from 5 bouts tracked for Eddie Menney and 73 bouts tracked for Jimmy Reagan. Method and activity splits reflect those bouts only.

Compare someone else

6 suggested matchups

Compare Menney with…

Compare Reagan with…

Someone else?

Release either fighter to put someone new in that slot — the other one stays put.

Eddie Menney vs Jimmy Reagan — record, stats and common opponents compared

Eddie Menney

Jimmy Reagan