Skip to main content
Kill The Body

and the head will die

Billy McCarthy vs Mysterious Billy Smith — record, stats and common opponents compared

Billy McCarthy

🇨🇦WELTERWEIGHT

Mysterious Billy Smith

Billy McCarthy (23-19-15) and Mysterious Billy Smith (37-25-27) are compared on record, finishing method, activity, and common opponents on Kill The Body. The two have met once. They share 1 common opponent.

McCarthy

23

Wins16 KO · 70%

19

Losses

15

Draws7 tracked bouts

Smith

37

Wins24 KO · 65%

25

Losses

27

Draws91 tracked bouts

Head to Head

Smith leads 1–0

Billy McCarthy and Mysterious Billy Smith have met 1 time; Smith leads 1–0.

Billy McCarthy and Mysterious Billy Smith have met 1 time; Smith leads 1–0.
Met1893Sep 20Series
Billy McCarthyFighter ALLost0–1W–L
Mysterious Billy SmithFighter BWWon1–0W–L
ResultPTS1Meeting

The Numbers

McCarthy 2 · Smith 4 of 6 measurable rows
McCarthySmith
Record
23-19-1537-25-27 (edge)
Win %0–100%
53.5%
56.7% (edge)
Wins by knockoutmax 24
16
24 (edge)
KO rate0–100%
69.57% (edge)
64.86%
Stoppage rate (tracked wins)†not comparable
—62%
Times stopped†max 8
3 (edge)
8
Title reignslevelmax 0
0
0
Bouts per year‡max 3.6
0.7
3.6 (edge)
Bouts trackedcoveragemax 91
7
91

† Counted from bouts Kill The Body has ingested, not a career total. · ‡ Across each fighter's tracked career span. · Bars are scaled per row — percentages on 0–100, counts against the larger of the two. Every figure is also printed as text.

Tale of the Tape

Height+2″
Billy McCarthy: 5′7″
Mysterious Billy Smith: 5′9″ (edge)
Agenot held
Billy McCarthy: No date of birth
Mysterious Billy Smith: Died aged 66
Stance
Billy McCarthy: Orthodox
Mysterious Billy Smith: Not recorded

Billy McCarthy left, Mysterious Billy Smith right, as everywhere on this page. Age is stated, not scored — neither age nor stance carries an edge.

How They Win

Tracked bouts only
Billy McCarthy0 wins · from 7 tracked bouts

Billy McCarthy: no tracked wins in the 7 bouts Kill The Body has ingested.

No tracked wins for McCarthy yet.

Mysterious Billy Smith37 wins · from 91 tracked bouts

Mysterious Billy Smith: 37 tracked wins — 23 by KO/TKO (62%), 9 on the cards (24%) and 5 by another method or unrecorded (14%). Counted from 91 bouts Kill The Body has ingested.

23 by KO/TKO 62%9 on the cards 24%5 by another method or unrecorded 14%

One square per tracked win. Counted from the bouts Kill The Body has ingested for each fighter — Billy McCarthy 7, Mysterious Billy Smith 91 — not from a career-complete method table.

Common Opponents

1 shared

1 shared · McCarthy better on 1

McCarthy

Opponent

Smith

  • Billy McCarthy

    Loss, TKO 7

    1896

    RyanMcCarthy better

    Mysterious Billy Smith

    0–3–3 against

    Loss, KO 4

    1902

    Loss, DQ 9

    1896

    Draw, PTS

    1895

    Loss, PTS

    1894

    Draw, PTS

    1894

    Draw, PTS

    1893

Both sides are set at the same size on purpose. Kill The Body does not score a second-round knockout above a split decision — the edge counts losses first and wins as the tiebreak, and the rest is yours to argue. Shared opponents are matched on fighter identity, not on name, so two different fighters with the same name never merge into one row.

Current Form

Oldest left · newest right

Billy McCarthy last boxed on Dec 21, 1896 — 47,419 days ago. McCarthy had lost the most recent, to Tommy Ryan.LLLDL

Dempsey Feb 1890Fitzsimmons May 1890Smith Sep 1893Dempsey Sep 1895Ryan Dec 18960.7 tracked bouts per year

Mysterious Billy Smith has lost two straight, after one straight win. Smith last boxed on Dec 29, 1915.LLWLL

Ryan Mar 1902Walcott May 1903Neill Jun 1910Cameron Jul 1911Root Dec 19153.6 tracked bouts per year

Common Questions

With the rows behind them
Have Billy McCarthy and Mysterious Billy Smith ever fought each other?
Yes. Billy McCarthy and Mysterious Billy Smith met once on September 20, 1893, and Mysterious Billy Smith won by PTS.
The meeting

LSep 20, 1893 · Smith · PTS

Head to Head ↓
Who has the better record, McCarthy or Smith?
Billy McCarthy is 23-19-15 and Mysterious Billy Smith is 37-25-27. Mysterious Billy Smith has the higher win percentage.
Records · win %

McCarthy23–19–1553.5%

Smith37–25–2756.7%

The Numbers ↓
Who has more knockouts, McCarthy or Smith?
Billy McCarthy has 16 knockout wins and Mysterious Billy Smith has 24. Mysterious Billy Smith has more.
Knockout wins · KO rate

McCarthy1669.6%

Smith2464.9%

The Numbers ↓
Do McCarthy and Smith have any common opponents?
Billy McCarthy and Mysterious Billy Smith share 1 common opponent: Tommy Ryan. Billy McCarthy fared better against 1 of them.
Shared opponent

Tommy RyanL0–3–3

Common Opponents ↓
Who is bigger, McCarthy or Smith?
Mysterious Billy Smith is the taller fighter at 174 cm, 5 cm above the other.
Height · reach

McCarthy169 cm

Smith174 cm

Tale of the Tape ↓
How much fight data does Kill The Body have on McCarthy and Smith?
This comparison is drawn from 7 bouts tracked for Billy McCarthy and 91 bouts tracked for Mysterious Billy Smith. Method and activity splits reflect those bouts only.
Bouts tracked · no edge

McCarthy7bouts

Smith91bouts

How They Win ↓

Compare someone else

6 suggested matchups

Compare McCarthy with…

Compare Smith with…

Someone else?

Release either fighter to put someone new in that slot — the other one stays put.